Key Takeaways
- Medical cost sharing involves communities pooling resources to cover unexpected medical expenses.
- Monthly shares typically cost 50-70% less than traditional insurance premiums.
- Plans work best for healthy individuals without pre-existing conditions.
- Members choose their own healthcare providers and negotiate costs directly.
- Popular providers include Medi-Share, Liberty HealthShare, and Samaritan Ministries.
- Enrollment is available year-round with no open enrollment restrictions.
What Is Medical Cost Sharing
Medical cost sharing represents a community-based approach to healthcare financing.
Unlike traditional insurance companies, medical cost sharing organizations operate as mutual aid societies. Members contribute monthly shares to a common pool that covers eligible medical expenses for the community.
These faith-based and ethical communities unite around shared values and healthy lifestyle commitments. Members typically abstain from smoking, excessive drinking, and drug use, which helps keep costs lower for everyone.
The concept stems from religious and ethical principles of mutual aid. Rather than paying insurance premiums to profit-driven corporations, members directly support each other’s medical needs through their monthly contributions.
Compare Pricing on the Best Insurance Plans Available
How Medical Cost Sharing Works
Medical cost sharing operates through a straightforward member-to-member support system.
Each month, members contribute a predetermined share amount based on their age, family size, and chosen coverage level. These funds flow into a collective pool managed by the sharing organization.
When members face eligible medical expenses, they submit bills to the organization. After meeting their Annual Household Portion (similar to a deductible), the community shares cover remaining costs up to the plan limits.
Members receive direct payments or reimbursements for covered expenses. The process typically takes 30-45 days once all documentation is submitted and reviewed.
Unlike insurance claims that go through complex approval processes, medical cost sharing decisions focus on whether expenses align with community guidelines and sharing principles.
Who Medical Cost Sharing Is For
Medical cost sharing works best for specific demographics seeking affordable healthcare alternatives.
Ideal candidates include:
- Young, healthy individuals aged 18-40 with minimal medical needs
- Families without chronic conditions or ongoing medical expenses
- Self-employed professionals seeking cost-effective coverage
- Faith-based individuals who align with community values
- People comfortable with higher out-of-pocket responsibility
Less suitable for:
- Individuals with pre-existing conditions requiring immediate care
- Those needing regular prescription medications
- People preferring guaranteed insurance benefits
- Families with high-risk health profiles
Most sharing communities require health questionnaires and impose waiting periods for pre-existing conditions, making them ideal for currently healthy members.
Benefits of Medical Cost Sharing
Medical cost sharing offers several advantages over traditional health insurance for qualified individuals.
Cost savings represent the primary benefit. Monthly shares typically range from $100-300 for individuals and $300-600 for families, compared to $400-800+ for comparable insurance premiums according to KFF health insurance premium data.
Provider flexibility enhances healthcare choices. Members select any licensed healthcare provider without network restrictions. This freedom allows direct negotiation with providers for better rates.
Transparent pricing eliminates hidden costs. Medical share plans clearly outline coverage limits, sharing guidelines, and member responsibilities upfront, unlike complex insurance policies with fine print exclusions.
Community support provides emotional benefits. Many members report feeling connected to their sharing community through prayer support, encouragement, and shared values during medical challenges.
Simplified billing reduces administrative hassles. Members typically pay providers directly and submit receipts for sharing, avoiding complex prior authorization requirements common with insurance.
Medical Cost Sharing vs Health Insurance
Medical cost sharing and traditional health insurance differ significantly in structure, regulation, and benefits.
Regulatory differences create distinct frameworks. Health insurance falls under strict state and federal regulations, while medical cost sharing operates as voluntary membership organizations with fewer regulatory requirements.
Coverage guarantees vary substantially. Insurance policies provide contractual coverage guarantees, whereas medical cost sharing offers discretionary sharing based on community guidelines and available funds.
Pre-existing condition handling differs dramatically. Insurance must cover pre-existing conditions immediately, while medical share plans typically impose 12-24 month waiting periods for pre-existing conditions.
Cost structures favor different demographics. Insurance spreads risk across diverse populations, while medical cost sharing pools primarily healthy, lifestyle-conscious members, resulting in lower costs.
Financial protection levels vary. Insurance provides unlimited coverage for essential benefits, while most sharing plans cap annual benefits at $1-5 million per incident.
Popular Medical Cost Sharing Providers
Several established organizations lead the medical cost sharing marketplace.
JHS Community DIVINE focuses on catastrophic coverage for healthy individuals comfortable with higher member responsibility amounts up to $15,000 annually.
Universal Thrive specializes in comprehensive medical cost sharing plans designed for diverse member needs. Their approach combines traditional sharing principles with contemporary healthcare accessibility.
OneShare Health provides flexible medical cost sharing options with various coverage levels and competitive monthly shares. Their plans focus on transparency and member choice in healthcare decisions.
Sedera Health offers innovative medical cost sharing solutions with modern technology platforms and streamlined member experiences. They emphasize efficient claims processing and member support.
Medi-Share operates as the largest Christian medical cost sharing community with over 400,000 members. Plans start around $200 monthly for individuals and offer up to $5 million in annual sharing.
Each organization maintains specific membership requirements, sharing guidelines, and community values that prospective members should carefully review.
How to Join or Get a Quote
Joining a medical cost sharing plan involves several straightforward steps.
Research organizations to compare sharing amounts and community values.
Complete health questionnaires honestly, as most require disclosure of medical history and lifestyle habits.
Schedule consultations with Personal Benefits Managers who can explain plan differences and identify the best fit.
Review waiting periods carefully, as most plans impose 12-month waiting periods for pre-existing conditions.
Submit applications with required health forms and initial sharing amounts to complete enrollment.
Compare Pricing on the Best HealthShare Plans Available
Conclusion
Medical cost sharing plans offer compelling alternatives to expensive traditional health insurance for young, healthy individuals seeking significant healthcare savings.
By joining communities of like-minded people committed to healthy lifestyles, members can reduce monthly healthcare costs while maintaining access to quality care.
However, medical cost sharing requires careful consideration of member responsibilities, coverage limitations, and personal health needs. These plans work best for healthy individuals comfortable with higher out-of-pocket costs and shared risk.
Ready to explore medical cost sharing options for your situation? Schedule a free consultation with one of our experienced Personal Benefits Managers to discuss plans, compare costs, and determine if medical cost sharing aligns with your healthcare needs and budget.
Further Reading:
Frequently Asked Questions (F.A.Q.)
Q: Are medical cost sharing plans considered health insurance?
A: No, medical cost sharing plans are not health insurance. They operate as voluntary membership organizations where members share each other’s medical expenses based on community guidelines.
Q: Do medical cost sharing plans satisfy ACA individual mandate requirements?
A: Medical cost sharing plans may qualify for religious exemptions from ACA requirements, but members should consult tax professionals for specific guidance.
Q: What happens if the sharing organization runs out of money?
A: Sharing is discretionary and depends on available funds from member contributions. Unlike insurance guarantees, sharing organizations cannot guarantee payment if insufficient funds are available.
Wiley is President of HSA for America. He believes that consumers should have choice and price transparency, so they can make the best healthcare decisions for their needs. Read more about Wiley on his Bio page.
